Clinton on being president and his new thriller

Former US President Bill Clinton and best-selling author James Patterson sat down with the BBC to discuss how real life informed their new political thriller, The First Gentleman.

What happens when the president’s husband is put on trial for murder? That’s the conundrum at the heart of former US President Bill Clinton and thriller maestro James Patterson’s latest collaboration, The First Gentleman. It’s a novel that only those two could conjure up, after the huge success of their earlier books, 2018’s The President Is Missing (three million copies sold) and The President’s Daughter (2021). Patterson is as big as they come in the thriller world (with more than 230 million books sold worldwide) but as Clinton, a long-time fan of the genre, tells the BBC: “it was just an adventure in my old age” when they first collaborated. And it’s clear while speaking to them in person just how much fun they’re still having together.

Their gripping new novel centres on US President Madeline Wright and husband, Cole Wright, a former professional American football star. He still carries the scars of his career and is looking for a purpose in the White House, as he fights to clear his name in a trial for the murder of a cheerleader more than 20 years ago. It’s a classic police procedural-meets-courtroom drama, as journalists, detectives and political operatives all work to uncover the truth behind who killed the cheerleader and to exonerate the First Gentleman – or to destroy him – and his wife’s political agenda. And, of course, the role of First Gentleman is one that President Clinton might have found himself taking on in 2017 if his wife, Hillary Clinton, had won the 2016 election against US President Donald Trump.

It’s clear that Bill Clinton’s presidency is still with him as he writes. “There were times in the White House, and not just when the Republicans were trying to impeach me, but when we were going through really controversial hard things, where I had the feeling that I was – in the minds of those covering me – more a storyline than a story. We tried to get all that in there.”

Rather than focussing the narrative on the First Couple, however, the book has a pair of journalists at its core. Independent investigative journalist and lawyer Brea Cooke and her partner, Garrett Wilson, are digging into the disappearance of Suzanne Bonanno, a cheerleader who the First Gentleman was seeing back when he was playing for the New England Patriots football team 17 years earlier. It looks like Wright might have killed her, as Cook and Wilson unravel what really happened and where her body might be. Inspired by an iconic pair like Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, Patterson sees it as natural that journalists would be at the novel’s centre, “journalists, sometimes they deserve what they get, but most journalists want to go after the truth… That’s what we want journalists to do.” 

Clinton, who had his own tussles with conspiracy-minded journalists through the years, agrees that even in an era of fevered partisanship honourable journalists will succeed: “I still think being able to stand up as a standout person who will tell the truth even when it means, ‘I was wrong, but here’s what I think the truth is.'” And when the story makes its Hollywood debut (it has been sold and is being written by Peaky Blinders‘ Steven Knight), it’s likely that Brea Cooke will be the central character – the journalist digging for the truth.

But The First Gentleman is not just a courtroom drama. It’s also likely the first thriller in history to have as a central part of the plot a grand bargain on the US debt and spending. Without spoiling the ending, let’s just say President Wright lays out how to solve entitlement spending and balance the budget. This book is coming out at the same time as Donald Trump and the Republican Party are laying out their own plans. Could President Wright’s proposal work? Patterson jokes: “We have a big, beautiful bill in our book.”

Sneaking in some substantive information is all part of how they see their books connecting, says Clinton: “I think people don’t mind learning something useful while being entertained by a hell of a good story.” In their first book it was cybersecurity, now it’s budget negotiations.

And on their third outing, what have the writing pair learned from each other? For Patterson, it’s all about research and authenticity, and after finishing his recent memoir, he’s more focused on “paying much more attention to the sentences… I think I’m better than I’ve ever been, between keeping it real and being really conscious of the sentences.”

But even for this experienced pair, the first drafts of this book were tough. Patterson admitted that: “In the beginning, it was a mess, honestly, which we’ve never had before. We did not have the president, and they were not good characters. The journalists were not good characters. We kind of knew what the story was, but the characters were just all wrong.” And then Clinton called him one night to say, “I have a real problem. I don’t give a damn about any of these people.” They added depth and scenes to draw the characters out.

But as much as they are warm collaborators, they’re also united by a certain outlook on life. Patterson describes it: “One of the things we have in common, I think we look at the world as not black and white. It’s always complicated. It’s subtle. There’s shades, and I think that’s one of the reasons we can work together.”

And in the end, what drives this novel to its twisting denouement is a sense of duty. Will the president do the right thing by her husband and by the country? The echoes are clear to Clinton: “One thing I know something about, when the other side declares war on you in the White House, you still have to show up and do the job.”

In a tumultuous moment, this thriller from a former president might offer an essential piece of advice for world leaders.

Lucas Wittmann is the executive director of the Unterberg Center for Poetry and Literature at the 92nd Street Y in New York. He was previously an editor at Time and The Daily Beast.

The First Gentleman by Bill Clinton and James Patterson is published by Century and is out now.